Taking the ACT is a crucial step in your college admissions journey. Many students focus on content (English grammar, math formulas, reading, science) — and rightly so — but even well-prepared students can lose points on test day because of avoidable mistakes. 

In 2025, when competition and scoring curves are tight, these minor errors can make a big difference.

What makes the ACT challenging is that it measures more than just subject mastery. It is designed to test your endurance, ability to perform under time pressure, and adaptability across various sections in a single sitting. 

Even students who have excelled in school can be caught off guard by the pace, structure, and mental stamina required. 

Success comes not only from knowing the material but also from anticipating potential pitfalls, mastering test-day strategies, and practicing under conditions that closely mirror the actual exam.

Why It’s Not Enough Just to Know the Content 

You might ask: “If I know all the grammar rules, formulas, reading skills, and science reasoning, how can I still make mistakes?” The truth is, the ACT is as much a test of test-taking strategy, stamina, pacing, and mental control as it is a knowledge exam. 

The difference between a 32 and a 34 might come down to guessing strategy, time management, or not checking for careless errors.

Content knowledge alone does not prepare you for the mental demands of the test. The ACT compresses dozens of skills into strict time limits, forcing you to balance accuracy with speed. Without strategies for pacing, prioritization, and error reduction, even high-achieving students can underperform.

This is why students with similar academic abilities often end up with very different ACT results; those who train for test-day scenarios and manage their energy wisely consistently score higher. Understanding that the ACT is a skill-based exam, not just a content-based one, is the first step to building a winning prep plan.

Mistake 1: Lack of a Structured Study Plan

What It Means

Many students jump into ACT prep without a roadmap. They might do a few practice problems here, read a grammar guide there, or skim science passages. However, they don’t plan which topics to cover, when to cover them, how many complete tests to take, or how to allocate revision time across sections.

Why It Matters

Without structure, you risk:

• Spending too much time on your strengths while neglecting weak areas
  
• Inconsistent progress
  
• Cramming near test day (inefficient and stressful)
  
• Losing track of which topics you’ve covered and which still need work
  

Inconsistent preparation also makes it harder to measure real improvement. Without milestones, you may plateau without realizing it. Colleges value consistency and progress, and your study schedule should reflect that.

How to Fix It

• Start with a diagnostic ACT to identify strengths and weaknesses.
  
• Create a block schedule: dedicate 3 days a week to content, 1 day to a timed section, 1 day to a full test or review.
  
• Set milestone targets (e.g., after 4 weeks, reduce English errors by 20%)
  
• Leave buffer weeks near the test for complete mock tests and revision.
  
• Build in time for review sessions to revisit mistakes and correct them.
  

To learn more about structured preparation, explore the AP Guru ACT Prep Program.

Mistake 2: Not Taking Enough Full-Length, Timed Practice Tests

What It Means

Students often solve isolated problem sets by chapter — in untimed or semi-timed mode — but postpone or reduce full-length, end-to-end practice tests.

Why It Matters

• The ACT is a test of stamina. Maintaining focus for ~3 hours (excluding breaks) is challenging.
  
• Timing in individual sections is different when fatigue and pressure build.
  
• You might have content knowledge, but still underperform because you haven’t internalized pacing.
  

Skipping full-length tests also prevents you from simulating real conditions. Test-day anxiety is much lower when you’ve already practiced under the same time pressure. As The Princeton Review notes, a top ACT mistake is ignoring timing practice (The Princeton Review).

How to Fix It

• Schedule at least 4–6 full ACTs spaced across your prep period.
  
• Simulate test-day conditions: a quiet room, strict timing, and the same calculator.
  
• Review every wrong or guessed question and log it.
  
• Focus not only on your score but also on endurance and consistency across sections.
  

For math-specific strategies, read ACT Math – Tips for Conquering Geometry Problems.

Mistake 3: Poor Time Management During Each Section

What It Means

Students often get stuck on a difficult question early, leaving insufficient time for later ones. Others fail to budget time for review.

Why It Matters

Each section has strict pacing: ~36 seconds per English question, 60 seconds per math problem, and 52 seconds per reading item. If you spend too much time on one, you may miss easier points later.

The ACT itself warns that time is one of the biggest challenges. Poor pacing can also increase stress, which leads to even more careless errors.

How to Fix It

• Use pacing goals: e.g., 10 questions every 9 minutes in English.
  
• Carry a watch to keep track of your checkpoints.
  
• Flag hard questions and return later.
  
• Always reserve 2–3 minutes for final review.
  
• Train with timed drills to build natural speed and accuracy.
  

If pacing is a challenge, check out The Art of Time Management for Standardized Tests.

Mistake 4: Guessing Blindly or Leaving Blanks

What It Means

Some students think leaving blanks is safer or guess completely at random. They may panic when time runs out and either bubble haphazardly or leave the last few questions unanswered altogether. Others guess without any process, treating every uncertain question as pure luck.

Why It Matters

The ACT does not penalize wrong answers. Leaving blanks wastes free chances. Random guessing gives you only 25% odds, but eliminating 1–2 wrong choices boosts your odds significantly. 

Over the course of 215 questions, even minor improvements in guessing accuracy can add 2–3 scaled points to your composite. That could be the difference between a good score and a scholarship-eligible score. 

Guessing intelligently is a valuable skill, and those who practice it consistently tend to earn higher marks.

How to Fix It

• Never leave blanks; always bubble something
  
• Eliminate wrong answers first (look for grammar errors, impossible math answers, or inconsistent science data)
  
• Practice “educated guessing” using backsolving or plugging in values.
  
• Train this habit in every mock test so it feels automatic.
  
• Mark tricky questions as you go, then use leftover time to refine guesses.
  
• Develop a consistent guessing strategy (e.g., always pick the same letter if you must guess blind at the very end)

Mistake 5: Careless Errors and Not Reviewing Work

What It Means

You know the content, but misreading “not,” forgetting a negative, or copying numbers wrong costs points. These errors usually happen when students rush, skip steps, or lose focus under time pressure. 

Careless mistakes are prevalent in math, where a single missed sign can alter the entire solution, and in English, where ignoring context can render an otherwise correct answer incorrect.

Why It Matters

Even a few careless mistakes can lower your composite score by multiple points. They’re frustrating because you already knew how to solve the question, but let minor oversights slip through. 

Over time, repeated careless errors accumulate to become missed opportunities for improvement. Students on Reddit agree that building a “mistake log” is one of the best ways to cut these down. If you don’t review your errors, you risk repeating them on test day.

How to Fix It

• Leave 1–2 minutes at the end of each section for a quick review.
  
• Keep an error log by type: misreading, arithmetic, grammar, mis-bubbling
  
• Slow down slightly on known trap types — better to spend five extra seconds than lose a whole question.
  
• Always re-read answers in context for English questions.
  
• For math, write every step clearly instead of solving mentally.
  
• Use scratch work effectively in science and math to avoid skipping details.
  
• Build the habit of checking units, negatives, and “except/not” wording as soon as you spot them.
  

To benchmark your performance, review What Is a Good ACT Score?

Mistake 6: Weak Strategy for the English Section

What It Means

Students often rely on “what sounds right” rather than grammar rules.

Why It Matters

The ACT English section is filled with traps: dangling modifiers, subject-verb errors, and comma misuse. Even strong writers can lose points without systematic knowledge of grammar. Ivy Lounge highlights that confusing subjects within prepositional phrases is a common trap.

How to Fix It

• Master grammar rules commonly tested
  
• Cross out prepositional phrases to find the subject.
  
• Substitute chosen answers back into the sentence for clarity.
  
• Track recurring errors in your log
  
• Practice applying rules quickly under time pressure
  

For examples of grammar-based prep, see Do Online SAT/ACT Classes Work?

Mistake 7: Misreading Data and Graphs in the Science Section

What It Means

Students assume deep science knowledge is needed when, in reality, the section is about interpreting graphs, charts, and experiments.

Why It Matters

Many lose points by misinterpreting axes, units, or experimental setups. College Prep notes that misreading data is the top mistake students make in ACT Science. Misreading one figure can lead to a chain of incorrect answers across multiple questions.

How to Fix It

• Always read experiment introductions to identify variables.
  
• Label graphs quickly in margins
  
• Focus on big-picture trends, not tiny details.
  
• Answer general questions first, then proceed to the detailed ones.
  
• Practice with a variety of science passages to build flexibility.
  

To connect test skills with a broader admissions strategy, explore 3 Ways to Build the Most Versatile College Application.

Other Factors That Influence ACT Success

While these seven mistakes are the most common, other factors can also influence your performance. Poor sleep, nutrition, or stress management can undermine months of preparation. 

Students who cram at the last minute, skip breakfast on test day, or forget essentials like their calculator and admission ticket may see their scores dip unnecessarily. Mental readiness is just as important as academic readiness. 

Establish a healthy routine, practice stress-management techniques such as deep breathing or visualization, and double-check logistics well in advance of test day. These small details can help create a calm mindset, allowing you to perform at your best when it matters most.

Another overlooked factor is the environment. Where and how you study can impact retention and focus. A clutter-free, consistent study space signals to your brain that it’s time to concentrate, while random or distracted study sessions often lead to poor recall under pressure. 

Similarly, students who ignore balance — overloading on prep without breaks, exercise, or downtime — are more prone to burnout. 

Treat ACT prep as a marathon, not a sprint: sustainable routines, mental clarity, and physical health all work together to help you perform at your highest level on test day.

Final Thoughts

The ACT is not just about knowing math formulas or grammar rules — it’s a test of focus, stamina, and thoughtful decision-making. 

The seven mistakes outlined above are the most common pitfalls, but they’re also the most avoidable. With the right strategies, you can protect yourself against lost points and maximize your score. 

By building a structured study plan, taking full-length practice tests, managing time effectively, avoiding blanks, double-checking work, learning rule-based grammar, and mastering science data interpretation, you set yourself apart from other test-takers.

A strong ACT performance can significantly influence scholarships, admissions, and even advanced placement at universities. Every point matters, and fixing these mistakes could mean the difference between a 29 and a 32 — or a 33 and a 35. 

Approach your preparation as a process of constant refinement. Maintain a detailed error log, simulate test conditions, and develop habits that make strategies second nature. 

Most importantly, remember that the ACT rewards consistency and resilience. If you train smart and avoid these pitfalls, you’ll walk into test day with confidence.

For expert guidance, resources, and personalized tutoring, explore the AP Guru ACT Prep Program. With structured study plans, mock exams, and one-on-one mentorship, you can avoid these mistakes and position yourself for your highest possible score.

‍